How to Choose a Rewards Credit Card

January 2025

<p>How to Choose a Rewards Credit Card</p>

When it comes to rewards credit cards, your first choice is the most important: deciding which card is right for you. There are different types of rewards credit cards, with different costs and different benefits. Some offer points you can collect and redeem for just about anything; others offer cash back on your purchases.

To make sure you're not leaving money on the table, here's what to look for (and what to avoid) in credit card rewards.

Review Fees and Benefits

Credit card fees include things like annual fees, regular annual percentage rate (APR), the cost for cash advances and balance transfers, overdraft protection, penalty interest, and late and returned payment fees. Look for cards with terms that align with your known spending habits.

For example, some premium travel rewards credit cards have annual fees that can be pricey. But a $450 annual fee on an ultra-premium card for frequent travelers might be justified if it includes an airport lounge club membership worth $500.

Many premium cards waive fees during the first year, a potentially valuable perk for new cardholders. If you don't expect to use certain card benefits, opt for a low- or no-annual-fee card. Likewise, if earning rewards is a priority, look for no-annual-fee cards with above-average rewards programs.

Additional reward credit card benefits can include:

  • Complimentary rental car protection
  • Purchase protection
  • Travel accident and cellphone insurance
  • Enhanced identity theft protection

Know How to Redeem Points

Pay attention to how you can redeem the rewards points you’ve earned, like cashback, gift cards, airline miles, travel packages and experiences, and even merchandise. When deciding what to use your points on, pay attention to the values, minimum redemption requirements, and processing times for each.

Additionally, know how much your points will be worth at redemption. Some cashback redemptions value points at $0.01 a piece, while others, like a designated cashback card, may give you a set rate. For example, the Key Cashback® credit card offers up to 2%1 cashback for every purchase you make.

Some rewards credit cards do promotions by month or quarter, like offering up to 5% cashback on gas or at restaurants. You can learn about these promotions by enrolling in your credit card issuer’s emails or staying up to date on their website or mobile app.

Watch for Expiration Dates on Rewards

Last but not least, don't let your credit card rewards expire. Pay attention to expiration dates and know what you need to do to ensure you don't leave money on the table. Consider adding a recurring appointment to your calendar to make sure all points are redeemed before the expiration date.

Prioritize your focus on rewards credit cards with benefits that suit your needs and spending habits so your rewards points can add up quickly.

Women shaking hands

Check in on Your Money

We'll talk about your money realities and your goals. Then, we'll provide personalized advice and ideas you can start using right away.

Content provided for informational and educational purposes only and is in no way to be construed as financial, investment, or legal advice. We cannot and do not guarantee their applicability or accuracy in regards to your individual circumstances. All examples are hypothetical and are for illustrative purposes. We encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding all personal financial issues.

1

To be eligible for 2% in Cashback Rewards, you must have an eligible open KeyBank consumer checking account (excluding a health savings account) with 5 or more qualifying transactions posted to that same checking account in a calendar month. Qualifying transactions include, but are not limited to, point of sale transactions, bill payment(s), ATM transactions, check, cash, or direct deposits, and electronic funds transfers. Qualifying transactions exclude balance transfers, convenience check transactions, overdraft protection transfers, quasi cash transactions, adjustments, cash advances, reversals, refunds, account to account transfers, person to person transfers, interest, service charges, and fees of any kind. You may also be eligible for 2% with an open eligible Key Private Bank checking account.

On the fourth business day of each month (“Evaluation Date”), we will determine whether you are entitled to earn 2% cash back by meeting the eligibility criteria during the prior month. Your 2% earnings will start on this date and apply until your next monthly evaluation (on the fourth business day of the following calendar month). New card accounts will receive at least a full calendar month at the 2% cash back rate prior to the first Evaluation Date. You will receive a grace period for the first month in which you do not meet the eligibility criteria. If you do not meet the eligibility criteria during the grace period, your rate for the month immediately following the grace period will be 1%, beginning on the Evaluation Date. Returns will reduce your cash back balance. See the Key Cashback® Credit Card Terms & Conditions for full details, which are subject to change and may be found at www.key.com/personal/credit-cards/key-cashback-terms-conditions.html

Call Us

1-800-KEY2YOU® (539-2968)

Dial 711 for TTY/TRS

Clients using a relay service:
1-866-821-9126

Schedule an Appointment

Talk to a Branch Manager in your neighborhood.

Schedule an appointment now

Find a Branch or ATM

Call Us

1-800-KEY2YOU® (539-2968)

Dial 711 for TTY/TRS

Clients using a relay service:
1-866-821-9126

Schedule an Appointment

Talk to a Branch Manager in your neighborhood.

Schedule an appointment now